Hong Kong Cinemagic
Version française English version
 Exclusive News   Capsule Reviews   English Board   Myspace   Facebook   Youtube  
 People
 Movies
 Movie Studios
 Glossary
 Your Settings

HKCine Search
Switch to Google Search
>> Help

 Drama & Opera

 Shaw Brothers
 Reports
 Film Industry
 Cultural & Societal

 Film directors
 Actors
 Technicians
 Producers

 DVD Tests
 HK Cinema Books
 Where to buy?

 OST & Music
 VIP Guestbook

 Site Map
 Editos Archives
 Staff
 Site History
 Links
 Visitor guestbook
 Aknowledgement
 HKCinemagic 1
 HKCinemagic 2




Capsule Reviews

Iron Fisted Monk    (1977)
 The Husker has a heart of gold although he is full of tricks. When he is a trainee at Shaolin Temple, he cuts so many corners and devises so many labor-saving ploys that he earns the open wrath and secret admiration of his holy elders. Monk Shan, the famous kung fu master, never lets his buddhist association stand in the way of wining, whoring and the partaking of dog meat. His student Niu Ching-Liang is in trouble as Niu's sister is raped by the Manchu and has committed suicide. The monk tells Niu to bide for time. (Joy Sales)

 Having starred and appeared in countless films by the time 1977 rolled around, Sammo Hung Kam Bo had yet to make his (inevitable?) transition to directorial duties. It’s true that up until this point, his skilful action direction had made its mark across dozens of films, yet his true invention and artistry was so far un-revealed. Having worked under many directors himself, could the opera school graduate and action star bring something new to the genre? 1977’s Iron-Fisted Monk is a career landmark for Sammo, and a milestone for this genre of film itself.

First, we are met with a disciple at the Shaolin Temple, (and here Casanova Wong makes his brief and only appearance as he spars with Husker (Hung)). Husker himself is the perfect hero-to-be: an able, generous, honest, hard-working but suitably impatient student with that crucial hint of mischievousness. But it’s his restlessness that is the driving force of the film; for his unsettled spirit (shown early on as a cause for his sleepless nights) forces him into action, breaking with friendships, his youth and the strict Shaolin code altogether.

Iron-Fisted Monk, while on the surface is at least a great action film, is also at heart a story of uprising, rebellion and personal vendetta. The Manchus (rulers of China in the Qing Dynasty), are the one enemy in this film, and their cruelty and dominance is demonstrated to the point of disgust. Their acts of violence and exploitation are directed at any Chinese – even children. This injustice is at odds with what Shaolin stand for (and common decency for that matter). Interestingly, this theme is later echoed in Jackie Chan’s Project A II, where the rebellious and true-to-life efforts of Sun Yat-sen are entwined with Jackie’s constabulary.

Husker finds solidarity within Brother Tak, played sturdily by Chan Sing. Here, an interesting mix of perspectives is found in the film – we have Tak as a father figure, experienced, righteous and refined. He is contrasted with the inexperienced and naivety of Husker’s youth. Husker’s impatience is kept in check by the Buddha-praising monk; he talks of exercising tolerance and sound judgement, yet we sense a massive, sleeping and ominous force behind these words. It is only after a humiliating scene where Husker is dishonoured by the Manchus that we discover Brother Tak’s limits. We see that even Shaolin, when faced with no other alternative, will kill for the good of the community.

The action sequences in this film are choreographed with care. We see a mix of playfulness and power in Huskers techniques, and we see a brutal effectiveness in Tak’s. Suitably, the villains in the film are each distinguishable in both their outfits and choice of weapons. Yes, the Manchus play dirty, and their brutality is absurdly enhanced by their eccentric hair-styles and deadly accessories. One specialised cold-hearted killer wears a mane of wild hair and swings a handy ball and chain, called a meteor hammer. But Sammo Hung’s attention to details, while not as formed as in his later films, still comes across clearly for the most part.

Edited with attention to the martial art rhythm, we see in the film controlled phrases of action rather than a drawn-out brawl or tiresome, careless blow-trading. Deliberate, powerful and fluid, the hand-to-hand scenes are memorable. Weapons are used throughout, but only fleetingly and frequent enough to add variety. And the Manchus really do pose a threat in these scenes; henchmen with glass-jaws they are not. Iron Fisted Monk develops the Manchurian characters as ruthless, violent and heartless, so viewers are sure to recall these characteristics when the showdown inevitably comes – the revenge is sweet, and arguably righteous.

Here, blows are traded fairly equally and it’s a spontaneous team-up of Husker and Tak’s techniques that set the finale apart from similarly plotted films. True, the lightning-fast action sequences and invention that appeared later in Hung’s career was yet to be perfected here, but the finale in the film is still a pleasure, and is somewhat of a pre-cursor to Hung’s emerging talents.

For a directorial debut, this film certainly is challenging. The cruelty shown really does come out of nowhere, and this plunges the film into a different class. No longer are we watching bad guys from a distance when they misbehave. We get up close and distressingly personal with scenes of rape and brazen cruelty. Sammo Hung had made two marks here. He showed that action choreography could be art all over again, and that his film direction has a noticeable hard edge (to be explored further later in his career). It’s a satisfying, demanding and worthy film, and the debut of one of Hong Kong’s most important directors.
Ryan Gobbe 10/24/2009 - top

Page Index
 Iron Fisted Monk

Latest Reviews
 Iron Fisted Monk
 Bodyguard: A New Beg...
 Shaolin Wooden Men
 Way Of The Dragon
 Enter The Dragon
 Game Of Death
 Big Boss
 Fist Of Fury
 Heavenly Kings
 Hong Kong Bronx
 Noble House
 Forbidden Kingdom
 Three Kingdoms - Res...
 Fatal Move
 Exodus
 In Love With The Dea...
 Naraka 19
 Sun Also Rises
 Rush Hour 3
 Running On Karma
 Invisible Target
 Eye In The Sky
 Single Blog
 Whispers And Moans
 Ming Ming
 Spider Lilies
 Twins Mission
 Protégé
 Eternal Summer
 Wo Hu
 Confession Of Pain
 Crime Story
 Hong Kong Godfather
 Don't Give A Damn !
 After This, Our Exil...
 Breaking News
 Battle Of Wits
 Triads - The Inside ...
 Century Of The Drago...
 Diary
 DOA : Dead Or Alive
 Banquet
 On The Edge
 Dog Bite Dog
 Re-Cycle
 Dragon Tiger Gate
 Mistress
 Hero Of Swallow
 Casino Raiders 2
 Date In Portland Str...
 Yellow River Fighter
 So Close
 Killing Skill
 Wall
 Going Home
 No Problem 2
 New Blood
 My Life As McDull
 My Wife Is Eighteen
 Mummy Aged 19
 Love Undercover
 Just One Look
 Demi-haunted
 Shark Busters
 Runaway Pistol
 July Rhapsody
 Inner Senses
 Infernal Affairs
 If U Care ...
 Hollywood Hong Kong
 Frugal Game
 Fighting To Survive
 Eye
 Chinese Odyssey 2002
 2002
 Tom, Dick And Hairy
 Dry Wood Fierce Fire
 Touch
 Web Of Deception
 Shanghai Blues
 Chinese Odyssey 2002
 Longest Nite
 Gorgeous
 In The Mood For Love
 Lost And Found
 King Of Beggars
 Legend Of The Dragon
 Dreadnaught
 Royal Tramp
 Sixty Million Dollar...
 Eagle Shooting Heroe...
 Mission
 Running Out Of Time
 Hero Never Dies
 Sword
 Dr Wai In " The Scri...
 East Is Red
 Terracotta Warrior
 Witch From Nepal
 Duel To The Death

 Advertise on HKCinemagic.com   Submit a review   Contact   FAQ   Terms of use   Disclaimer   Error Report  
copyright ©1998-2009 hkcinemagic.com